When a collegiate head coach makes staff changes because he believes it is the right thing to do, it’s usually ends up being a good thing for his program. However, when athletics directors mandate staff changes to make a show for the fan base, it usually blows up in everyone’s faces.
By the way John Pelphrey praised Isaac Brown in his press conference Friday and the fact Brown is moving to an administrative role within Arkansas’ basketball program says volumes about his re-assignment, to me.
If Pelphrey thinks so highly of Brown and the job he has done, why move him out of a coaching position?
Is Brown that good at pushing papers?
It seems, Pelphrey was coerced or forced into making some kind of sacrifice on the alter of failure to assure Razorbacks fans that something is being done about the back-to-back losing seasons the program has suffered.
The situation is not unique to Arkansas, and it has gone on for years in collegiate coaching circles.
When a head coach is fired, go back and check and see if he didn’t fire some assistants or make some staff changes the previous year. The method seems to be taught in Athletics Management 101, but it’s a page that should be torn out of the book.
Again if a head coach decides he needs to make staff changes, I’m fine with that. A head coach has to trust his staff. But to fire or re-assign a good employee for public relations purposes is a callous move to the coaching profession and a condescending one to the fan base.
Personally, I hope Brown finds himself an even better coaching job elsewhere, and the praise that Pelphrey gave him during a press conference Friday was probably aimed at helping Brown do just that. One thing that will work in Brown’s favor is that the coaches he will likely interview with understand the game and know his re-assignment was a political move.
Now, that Pelphrey needs to hire an assistant, it would behoove Arkansas athletics director Jeff Long to let him do it without further meddling. Certainly, if Long has suggestions or contacts, he should offer them to his head basketball coach, but he should not force a coach down Pelphrey’s throat.
Arkansas’ previous athletics director Frank Broyles was bad about doing that with his football coaches, who found themselves on the ropes. Now, in my estimation, Broyles was a fantastic athletics director and what he built at the UA with the resources he had on hand is incredible. It’s very likely nobody could have done as much.
But when Broyles began to micromanage his head football coaches’ staffs, bad things happened. Broyles and his former player Ken Hatfield were at odds over staff changes Hatfield would not make in the late 1980s. The feud led to Hatfield bolting to Clemson after winning back-to-back Southwest Conference titles in 1988 and 1989. Arkansas’ football program did not recover for nearly a decade.
Broyles forced Danny Ford to hire former Buffalo Bills head coach Kay Stephenson as his offensive coordinator for the 1997 season. Ford liked running the football and Stephenson excelled at the passing game. The two philosophies clashed and both were unemployed by the end of November.
And of course there was the whole Nutt-Malzahn affair. While Gus Malzahn has proven he was up to the task of being a collegiate offensive coordinator and then some by his success at Arkansas, Tulsa and now Auburn, Houston Nutt did not want him to fill that position on his staff. Unfortunately, we all remember how that worked out. The pettiness and strife involved in that fiasco might have cost Arkansas two SEC titles.
It’s my opinion, a head coach should have the right to hire the staff he wants within the means of the athletic department’s budget. The head coach needs to have the power to run his program as he sees fit. When he’s not afforded that ability, things just don’t seem to work out.
If an athletics program is in such a bad situation that the A.D. needs to begin making moves, then it’s probably time to clean house.
Obviously, Long does not believe that’s the case with Pelphrey, and I believe he’s right. Given the set of circumstances with which Pelphrey has had to work — admittedly some of his own creation — I don’t believe Pelphrey has had enough time to restore Arkansas’ basketball program to consistent success.
But if Long is going to stand by Pelphrey, he needs to allow Pelphrey manage his own program and let him swim or sink based on his own decisions. And as for the cosmetic changes, leave that up to Max Factor and Revlon.